Peer Editing Checklist – 3 peer review checklists & forms for effective editing


Make peer editing effective, accessible, and engaging with these peer editing checklists! This peer review resource includes 3 forms for peer editing that help guide students as they complete a thorough and effective peer review. Includes peer editing checklists for argument, narrative, and informative writing!

Provide your students with the guidance and tools they need to become better writers and editors with these peer review checklists. With one form for each major writing strand, you’ll be able to use these peer editing checklists, again and again, all year long!

This peer editing resource includes the following:

  • Argument writing peer editing checklist
  • Narrative writing peer editing checklist
  • Informative/expository writing peer editing checklist

Your students will love the extra support they receive with these forms. Students will have a game plan for tackling peer editing, and in the process, students will provide and receive stronger peer feedback. Students will be able to complete effective peer editing with these forms.

These forms guide students through the peer edit process checking for organization, style, MLA format, and content development for each of the writing disciplines: argument, narrative, and informational.

Prep is quick and easy… Just select which peer editing checklist you would like to use in your classroom and print out enough copies! To have students review multiple essays, you can print these forms double-sided for two reviews per essay!

Looking for more peer editing? Check out my stations:

Peer Editing Stations and Rotations


⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ “Just what I needed to motivate my students when doing peer editing. Sometimes they lack the direction to complete the activity but these will keep them on task. Thank you!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ “I have tried so many different peer editing sheets. This one, by far, was the easiest for my students to complete while still keeping the academic rigor high. I will be using this resource again and again. Thank you so much!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ “Students are very uneasy about grading their peers. This resource takes out the stress and makes it easy to give comments to their peers.


You may also like…

Ultimate Argument Writing Bundle (Grades 7-12)

Annotating Text Made Easy

Writing Rubrics for Secondary ELA


Helpful Advice:

* Make sure you click the “follow” button next to my picture so you don’t miss out on sales and new resources

* Please provide feedback on this resource. Doing so will help you earn TPT credits that you can apply toward future purchases! It’s like FREE TPT cash!

© The Daring English Teacher, Inc.

All rights reserved. License good for single-classroom use only.